The Good Cop
Josh GrobanTony Caruso Jr.
Tony DanzaTony Caruso Sr.
Monica BarbaroCora Vasquez
Isiah Whitlock Jr.Burl Loomis
Bill KottkampRyan Domki- BBrooke CarrellDetective
John ScurtiWendell Kirk
Victor CruzSergeant Rudner- MMatthew SaldivarGordy
Glenn FitzgeraldFather Kokesh
Frank WhaleyJoseph Privett
Alice SpivakMrs. Spiro
Molly PriceCaptain
Ann MahoneyPhillis, Phyllis
Adam DeCarloCSI Tech
Stacey RaymondAnother Uniform Cop
Rebecca RittenhouseMacy Clark
Connor TillmanDeputy Tillman
Emma IshtaBelinda Mannix
Christopher James BakerCorey Speck
Teddy ColucaAl Monte
Andrew DolanLionel Sykes
Alanna UbachDebbi Paddock
Joe HoltAgent Conway
Aaron SerotskyAgent Hodges
Chaka DeSilvaRemy DeRosa
Bob SagetRichie Knight
Andy GrotelueschenDr. Alvin Roundie
Billy MaloneSergeant Chet Finch
OrfehDonna Livingston
John Carroll LynchSherman Smalls
David FurrMickey- MMargo SeibertLois Ronstadt
C. Thomas HowellBusinessman
Joy SupranoJocelyn
Brooke LangtonJoy- EEdward CarnevaleDorfirio Santini
Dan ByrdDonovan Demark
Caroline AaronOlivia Nyborg
Alyssa CheathamYoung girl- LLynn MarocolaNYPD (uncredited)
Alexander FloresStork
Alex WebbInspector Quinn
Mattea ConfortiYoung Niece- SSedly BloomfieldLandlord
- AAgnes ChungNews Reporter
- MMax DanielsJack Livingston
Diane FindlayFriendly Aunt
Ron ScottPolice Union Rep- SScott AielloSgt. Aiello
Greg CroweBarbershop Customer
Stan DemidoffSgt. Stanley
Ambrose MartosCurious Hal- DDave MizzoniSecond Fan
Jun NaitoForensic Investigator- AAriel PadillaBig Fan
Ellen RatnerMrs. Zucker
Gurdeep SinghMr. Patel- SSteven SolisFrankie Storch
Justin AhdootCollege Student- JJason Michael EvansMasked CSI Officer
Gina FerrallQuinlan's Secretary
Fred InkleySgt. Wickes
Jamil A.C. ManganState Trooper
Christopher MannPrison Warden- AAlex OrthweinGuy at Ringside
Hannah D. ScottBrooke Smalls- HHannah TinkerHelen Quinlan
- AAllan R. WalkerReferee
Andre B. BlakeDr. Kornbluth
Steve CirbusNolan Zander- RReade KellyJoey Wingate
- EEden MalynCynthia
Harry Sutton Jr.Dale Coruthers
O'Neil ThomasShoe Rental Guy
Bill TimoneyAlley Manager- CCory CandrilliCoranet Reality Bowler
- MMelissa O'DonnellJoey's Niece
Jose Guns AlvesEnforcer
Carly BrookeJolene- CChris DoiFirst Paramedic
Gavin HaagFBI Special Agent #2
Jo D. JonzFBI Special Agent #1
Thomas KopacheMr. Entwhistle- LLarissa LaurelSecond Paramedic
Geraldine LeerDeRosa's Lawyer
Michael NostrandLaundromat Manager
Marcos PalmaRoach- SShaun ReyEnrico Kraus
- LLeila SbitaniLocal Reporter
- AAnthony VincentStreet Musician
- TTony WhiteBartender
Michael-Scott DruckenmillerFDNY Paramedic- HHugo Salazar Jr.Agent Rhinehart
- JJoseph DellgerStudio Official
Alix EliasMrs. Prima
Jacqueline GuillenFirst Volunteer- MMary NeelyBackstage PA
- TTerrence ShinglerStudio Guard
Kensington TallmanAmateur Magician- TTam YoungSecond Volunteer
- QQuentinLoud audience member
Kate GrimesKaren Trumbo
Andy TaylorSheriff Gaddy- BBrennan TaylorAndre Rifkin
Bryan BurtonFrank Malton the Desk Clerk- DDonald FloresMaintenance Worker
- AAaron David KapnerFriendly Cop
Maximillian McNamaraDaryl Teasdale
Dean NeistatSkier
Angel PaiAttractive Woman- CClaire SaundersMacy's Desk Clerk
- PPablo ThomasSki Instructor
Ashlyn AlessiLodge Staff- DDomenico Del GiaccoHarry
Josh SegarraWarren
Stephanie KurtzubaEvelyn
Clyde BaldoStax
Jeffrey BeanCity Clerk- JJohn GoodlowOfficiant
- CChristopher Joseph GrayPatrol Officer
- CCharmar JeterBar Patron
- RRicardo CortésYoung Busboy
- LLeila GraceAdorable Girl
Tristan GriffinUniform Cop- CCarlos IbarraPorfirio Santini (Busboy)
Marty KrzywonosFrankie the Risotto Lover- TTodd LewisFirst Financier
Mike MassiminoJohnny
Ava Lee ScottWoman with Necklace
Jacqueline SpringfieldNurse
Kazy TauginasFirst Gangster- DDamir MrkulicN.Y.P.D / Swat
- DDavid NegriPaulie's Friend
Thaddeus DanielsHenry the Doorman
Bonnie FlanneryNeighbor in Window
Wai Ching HoDr. Kim
Lane NapperUniform Cop
Barbara SingerMrs. Ackroyd- CCarol ToVera
- DDanielle FarrierDonovan's Mother