The Dating Game Killer
Anna KendrickSheryl Bradshaw
Daniel ZovattoRodney Alcala
Nicolette RobinsonLaura
Jedidiah GoodacreBachelor #2
Autumn BestAmy
Pete HolmesTerry
Kelley JakleSarah
Kathryn GallagherCharlie
Tony HaleEd
Matt VisserBachelor #1
Rob MortonCustodian (George Elliot)
Dylan SchmidMario
Karen HolnessGretchen
Denalda WilliamsMarilyn
Jessie FraserLisa
Matty FinochioCasting Director
Geoff GustafsonCasting Director
Max Lloyd-JonesKen
Andy ThompsonBob
Nancy KerrDiane
James YiJoe
Jessica ChaffinHelen
Matthew Kevin AndersonMark
Taylor HastingsMelanie
David BeairstoRodney's Boss
Darcy LaurieMarty
Marc GaudetHead Mover
Bonnie HayBartender
Michael AdamthwaiteDating Game Director
Jacob WoikeDating Game 1st Assistant Director
Jason SimpsonDating Game Announcer
Hannah HenneyBachelorette (Playback)
Tighe GillBachelor (Playback)
Michael JonssonBooth Security Guard (Harold)- VVonnie BennettoTypist
Thomas StrumpskiLaundromat Owner
John HerkenrathDetective
Jeremy RadinDetective
Cody HellerAlison