Shirley
Elisabeth MossShirley Jackson
Odessa YoungRose Nemser / Paula
Michael StuhlbargStanley Hyman
Logan LermanFred Nemser
Victoria PedrettiKatherine
Robert WuhlRandy Fisher
Paul O'BrienDean
Orlagh CassidyCaroline
Bisserat TseggaiPeggy
Allen McCulloughNorman
Tony MannaDrunken Fellow
Molly FaheyFaculty Wife- EEdward O'BlenisRalph Ellison
Ryan SpahnDrunk Cad- EEmily DeckerPrissy College Girl
- AAlex ShermanPaula
- AAva LangfordRose's Friend
- TThomas RacekParty Guest
Lexa HayesParty Goer
Adelind HoranPaula Double (uncredited)
Steve VinovichHenry (uncredited)